What the CMA fined in October 2026
On 14 October 2026 the UK Competition and Markets Authority announced its first fines for misleading time-limited offers under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC Act). Wayfair was fined £4.8 million: according to the CMA, its Daily Deals and 24-hour Flash Deals used countdown timers and messages such as “Here Today, Gone Tomorrow”, yet many products remained available at the same price or lower after the stated deadline. Appliances Direct was fined £1.2 million and will pay around £432,000 in refunds; among other issues, pop-up countdown banners offered £10 to £25 off “for a limited time”, but the same discount codes appeared repeatedly over many days. The third firm fined that day, Gold's Gym, was sanctioned for leaving its joining fee out of the total price. All three admitted the breaches, settled early and received a 40% reduction.
The legal hook is short. Schedule 20 of the DMCC Act lists as unfair in all circumstances falsely stating that a product will only be available for a limited time, or only on particular terms for a limited time, in order to elicit an immediate decision. The EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive contains the same practice in its Annex I (point 7), transposed in every member state. The CMA can now fine directly, up to 10% of global turnover. Its case page sums up the Wayfair investigation in one line: whether time-limited sales ended when they said they would.
Why one screenshot cannot show that an offer ended
That question cannot be answered by a single capture. A screenshot of a timer at 23:58 shows that a deadline was announced. It says nothing about what the page showed at 00:05, the next morning or a week later. The fact that matters, whether the price or the code was still available after the deadline, only appears when the same page is recorded before and after the stated end, with a reliable date on every record.
The same is true in reverse. A retailer that did end its offer on time has the same problem: without its own dated records, “it ended at midnight” is an assertion. Advisers are saying so before the sale season. Charlie Markillie of Knights told Retail Times on 27 October 2026: “Keep records that support your pricing and promotional claims, in case the CMA asks.” How the CMA gathered its evidence in these cases is not stated in its announcement, and we do not speculate about it.
What a defensible record of a time-limited offer contains
Whichever side you are on, a record of a time-limited offer is useful when someone else can check these points without having to trust you:
- The exact URL and the offer as shown: the claim (“24 hours only”, “ends tonight”), the timer, the price and any discount code.
- A record shortly after the offer starts and one shortly after the stated deadline, plus later ones showing whether the price or code came back.
- The same page on the following days, including days when nothing changed, because an unchanged price after the deadline is exactly the point.
- Pop-ups and banners preserved in the page source and video, not only in a stitched screenshot, since overlays are where many urgency claims live.
- A trustworthy date on each record and integrity protection, so nobody can argue that the files were edited or re-dated later.
If you run the promotion: keep your own dated record
For an in-house legal or compliance team the aim is not to collect every page, but to be able to substantiate each urgency claim if asked. A practical routine:
- Keep a register of live promotions: page, claim, start and end time, and who approved it.
- Record the promotion page when the offer goes live and again after the end time, to show that the price, code or banner really changed.
- For recurring codes and rolling daily deals, keep a daily series for the whole campaign, so you can show how often a code or deal was actually offered.
- Store the records by campaign, so that a regulator's question or a customer complaint can be answered with one folder.
A record does not make a promotion lawful and will not prevent enforcement. It lets you show what you actually did, which helps when answering a complaint or a request quickly, and it is also how teams notice a timer that a developer forgot to switch off.
If you are watching a competitor or acting for consumers
Competitors, trade bodies and consumer organisations face the opposite task: showing that a limited time was not limited. The series is the evidence, so start it while the offer is running:
- Record the page while the countdown runs, together with the deadline it states.
- Record it again after the deadline and on the following days; a price that stays the same or drops is the pattern the CMA described at Wayfair.
- Where a pop-up code is involved, record every day on which the code is offered, as in the Appliances Direct pattern of codes appearing repeatedly.
- For offers that only appear in the basket or after login, use a capture that follows the steps in one browser session, not a single URL.
How this works with GetProofAnchor
GetProofAnchor seals web captures with a qualified eIDAS timestamp from an EU-listed qualified trust service provider. A server capture stores a full-page screenshot, the HTML, an MHTML snapshot, a video of the page, the network log (HAR), TLS and DNS data; every artifact is bound by SHA-256 into the timestamp, so any later change to a sealed artifact is detectable offline with the open-source gpa-verify.
- Website Monitoring: scheduled daily or weekly checks of a promotion page, every check a sealed proof, with an e-mail when the page changes. Business (99 EUR per month excl. VAT) includes 10 monitors; Monitoring 50 (399 EUR) and Monitoring 100 (599 EUR) cover larger catalogues and competitor sets.
- Manual captures at the moments that matter, such as just after a deadline, from the web app by URL or with the browser extension; Cases group them by campaign and export the whole campaign as one ZIP.
- Forensic Browser (Windows, from 290 EUR per year) for multi-step flows: the product page, the pop-up code and the basket in one session and one sealed package.
- Assisted Capture when a competitor's countdown is running now and you have no account: Rush, 249 EUR excl. VAT, with a 60-minute guarantee.
If you want to see what such a record looks like, send one promotion URL to sales@getproofanchor.com and we will capture it and send you the evidence package free of charge.
Limits you should state honestly
- A series only covers the days from when it starts. Monitoring cannot reconstruct what a page showed last week.
- Monitoring checks run daily or weekly, not continuously; a deadline at midnight needs a capture scheduled or made just after it.
- The screenshot is a stitched render: fixed overlays may be hidden or de-duplicated, and every such intervention is listed in the sealed metadata. The HTML, MHTML and video are the authoritative record of a pop-up.
- In the EU a qualified timestamp is presumed accurate as to its date and time and the integrity of the stamped data (eIDAS Art. 41(2)) and is recognised in all member states (Art. 41(3)). It does not prove that the content is true, and before a UK authority or court the record is evidence to be weighed, not an EU presumption.
Checklist before Black Friday (27 November 2026)
- List every page that will carry a countdown, “ends tonight” or “limited time” claim.
- Decide who records each page at launch and after the deadline.
- Schedule daily checks for the whole campaign, not only for the launch day.
- Check that codes advertised as time-limited are actually withdrawn when the timer ends.
- After the campaign, record the pages once more to show the end state.
- Keep the records by campaign, next to the approval trail.
FAQ
Are countdown timers illegal in the UK?
Is one screenshot of the timer enough?
Will keeping records protect us from a CMA fine?
Can monitoring show what our page looked like last month?
Does this matter outside the UK?
Sources
- CMA: CMA fines firms £6 million for misleading sales tactics (14 October 2026)
- CMA case page: Wayfair consumer protection enforcement case
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20
- Directive 2005/29/EC (Unfair Commercial Practices Directive), Annex I
- Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 (eIDAS), Article 41
- Retail Times: Why are online retailers being fined for unlawful sales tactics? (27 October 2026)
- Bates Wells: Sale season is coming – are your promotions ready and compliant? (10 November 2026)
For compliance and audit teams
Prove what was published — and when it changed
Scheduled forensic captures of policies, prices, disclosures and competitor claims. Every run is a sealed proof with an eIDAS qualified timestamp, building an unbroken evidence series.
Related guides
-
Website MonitoringDaily or weekly sealed checks of the pages you need to prove
-
Fake Black Friday discounts and the EU 30-day ruleReference prices and strikethrough discounts
-
Capturing a dynamic website for complianceHow to record pages built by scripts, pop-ups and banners
-
Tracking policy and pricing changesTerms, privacy and pricing pages that quietly change
-
PricingBusiness, Monitoring 50 and Monitoring 100 plans
Prove when the offer ended
Seal your promotion pages before and after each deadline with a qualified eIDAS timestamp, or send us one URL for a free sample.
Prices excl. VAT. A record supports your account of events; it does not guarantee any outcome.